Which Scenario
 

Well you obviously deserve to be punished so I can't possibly go for Option 6. However, on reflection, Scenarios 1-5 do all seem to be rather excessive. Can I suggest six of the best with the cane over tight jeans (bent over a couch or desk) every day for a week?

it seems to be a long vote i saw this three months ago on another site

Hello there
 

i agree with aurora . spanking doesnt come naturally to some people it took me 3 yrs to find the one for the lifestlye .. but i am not a newbie to spanking

I agree with the rest, spanking is not a magic cure all. You have to trust and you have broke the trust.
I know for me, I would be heart broken, that my trust had been broke and a spanking would not fix the heart.
My love and I have a golden rule, He does not spank me when he is as angry as I know your boyfriend is, because it will not be done in loving correction or passion, but in anger and thats not what spanking is about.

A spanking is not the answer but a new girlfriend is.